Fire door manufacturers cut corners and pass off substandard products as compliant, with the majority of their offerings failing to meet quality standards.
2012-08-06 09:41

Fires occur frequently, yet fire doors—designed to prevent fire spread, contain smoke, and withstand high temperatures—“fail to perform their intended function.” (Photo by Cao Yi)
“What if you don’t have a fire‑proofing certificate? We’ll use your brand to manufacture fire doors,” one company with a valid fire‑proofing certificate boldly advertises, actively courting business in the fire door market.
Fire door inspections are easily influenced by the subjective judgment of inspectors: “If they let you pass, you pass; if they don’t, you don’t.” However, for companies that maintain strong ties with local fire authorities, the situation is quite different.
Originally, it kept the grim reaper of fire at bay; now, that “door god” has lost its armor.
This is the reality of China’s “door capital”—the fire‑door manufacturing industry in Yongkang, Zhejiang. Fire doors that are supposed to resist fire, contain smoke, and withstand high temperatures “do not actually provide fire protection.”
In the past, the Yongkang door‑manufacturing cluster—along with the neighboring Wuyi County—accounted for as much as 70 percent of China’s burglar‑proof door output. As high‑rise buildings became more common, fire safety emerged as a top priority, prompting an increasing number of Yongkang manufacturers to shift their focus to producing fire‑rated doors.
Between May and July 2012, reporters from Southern Weekly conducted an investigation in Yongkang, Wuyi, and other locations in Zhejiang Province and found that fire door manufacturers were engaged in a host of irregularities, including cutting corners on materials, passing off inferior products as superior ones, and relying on personal connections to pass inspections.
Fire doors suffer from “rickets”
A thick layer of dust has accumulated on the machine, and its screws are heavily rusted; a casual swipe across the surface leaves two deep scratches. This massive, dust‑covered piece of equipment, left idle for years, is called a vacuum‑boosting, heat‑treatment, flame‑retardant processing unit—a crucial piece of machinery in the production of wooden fire doors.
“This flame-retardant device hasn’t been used in two years; it was only deployed back then when we applied for a fire‑safety certificate and during the factory’s acceptance inspection,” said Hu Qiang, deputy general manager of the fire door division at Zhejiang Jinhemei Industrial & Trading Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Jinhemei). Located in the Huajie Industrial Zone of Yongkang, Jinhemei has an annual production capacity of over 100,000 fire doors.
Flame-retardant treatment refers to the application of flame‑retardant coatings or processes to the wood used in the door leaf and frame’s structural framework. It is understood that the frames and door leaf frameworks of wooden fire doors are typically fabricated from softwoods such as pine and fir; prior to assembling the framework, the wood must undergo thorough flame‑retardant treatment. In the review criteria for fire‑safety certification, the fire department designates wood flame‑retardant treatment as a critical process and explicitly requires manufacturers to equip themselves with vacuum‑pressure, heated‑temperature flame‑retardant treatment equipment.
According to information released by the Fire Product Conformity Assessment Center of the Ministry of Public Security, nine enterprises in the Yongkang and Wuyi areas hold qualifications to manufacture wooden fire doors. A survey conducted by a Southern Weekend reporter of six of these companies revealed that four had failed to apply the required flame-retardant treatment to their wood. Moreover, most of these manufacturers only use their flame-retardant equipment briefly when applying for production certification; once they begin large-scale manufacturing, such equipment is often left idle.
Industry experts told a Southern Weekend reporter that the door frame and the door leaf’s structural framework support the entire fire door, while flame‑retardant and heat‑insulating filler materials such as perlite boards are secured within the door by this framework. If the wood is not treated with a flame retardant, it essentially develops “soft‑bone disease”: in the event of a fire, the framework will burn, causing the door leaf to warp or even collapse, thereby rendering the fire door incapable of providing thermal insulation or smoke containment.
More than one corporate sales representative has stated that, at present, Class B wood‑fire doors on the market may pass fire‑testing by the fire department, but not a single Class A fire door meets the standards. Fire‑testing refers to the fire department’s practice of subjecting fire doors to flame exposure to evaluate their fire‑resistance and smoke‑tightness performance. Typically, a Class A fire door must withstand at least 90 minutes of fire exposure, while a Class B door must endure a minimum of 60 minutes.
Like wooden fire doors, steel fire doors are also rife with hidden dangers. An investigation by a Southern Weekly reporter of more than twenty steel door manufacturers revealed that only a handful produce in strict compliance with certification standards—there is ample room for cutting corners in everything from raw materials and fillers to sealing strips and fire‑rated locks.
Buying and selling fire safety permits
A survey by a Southern Weekly reporter found that, in addition to substandard fire door quality, many fire door manufacturers are also engaged in another line of business.
At present, the state imposes strict licensing requirements on the manufacture of fire doors; manufacturers must pass both a factory‑condition inspection and product type‑approval testing to obtain authorization to produce fire doors.
According to data published on the China Fire Products Information Network, as of the end of April 2012, a total of 49 enterprises in Yongkang and Wuyi held qualifications to manufacture fire doors. However, a reporter from Southern Weekend found that the number of companies producing and selling fire doors far exceeds this figure.
Zhejiang Xing’an Industry and Trade Co., Ltd., located in the Xiali Creek Industrial Zone of Yongkang City, does not hold a fire‑safety permit yet it is manufacturing fire doors. The company’s chairman, Zhang Xingguang, stated that they are capable of producing fire doors, but these must bear other brands rather than Xing’an’s own label, as they rely on third‑party fire‑safety permits.
Wuyi County Hongfu Hardware Industrial Co., Ltd. is also manufacturing fire doors without a license. The sales department manager stated, “We don’t have a fire‑door production license; we buy them from others—at a price of 30 to 50 yuan per ID card.”
“What if you don’t have a fire‑proofing certificate? We’ll use your brand to manufacture fire doors.” Zhejiang Jingang Power Machinery Co., Ltd., which does hold such a certificate, has even launched an advertising campaign to attract business.
At the Yongkang Hardware City, Zhejiang Tangmen Metal Structure Co., Ltd. has even set up a sales outlet to solicit OEM business. Headquartered in Yiwu, this company is a participant in the development of the national fire door standards and places great importance on Yongkang’s OEM manufacturing sector.
In the production workshop of Yongkang Feitian Industrial and Trading Co., Ltd., a Southern Weekend reporter spotted two products bearing the brand logos of other companies—one labeled “Shanghai Zheng Fire Door” and the other “Dongyang Kangzhuang Door Industry.”
Fire doors are subject to tiered management based on fire‑rating standards and product quality. However, during an interview with Southern Weekend at Zhejiang Qianyita Fire Technology Co., Ltd., the reporter found that the same model of wooden fire door can be labeled either as a Class B door or as a Class A door.
“If you want a Class B license, wouldn’t it be better if I gave you a Class A certificate?” said the sales representative from Qianyita Company.
Costs are soaring—who’s really delivering fire protection?
Typically, the standardized wood flame‑retardant treatment involves the following steps: after drying, the lumber is loaded into a vacuum pressure vessel; a flame‑retardant solution is then injected into the vessel, and the pressure is increased to ensure thorough impregnation of the wood. The high‑pressure soaking process generally lasts at least six hours. Finally, the treated lumber is removed, air‑dried, and kiln‑dried before it can be used to fabricate door frame components.
After being soaked in a flame-retardant solution, wood typically undergoes deformation; consequently, the flame-retardant treatment consumes substantial amounts of timber—so much so that “out of 100 logs, only twenty to thirty remain usable after the impregnation process.”
“Flame-retardant treatment for the gantry frame is generally not included; if you want it, there’s an additional charge of 60 yuan per square meter,” Hu Qiang said.
Shrewd merchants are meticulous planners: adding 60 yuan per square meter boosts the cost of each door by over a hundred yuan, and with 100 doors, that adds up to more than ten thousand yuan—while the overall project cost swells by several hundred thousand.
Sources familiar with the matter told a Southern Weekend reporter that a qualified Class B wooden fire door should cost at least 300 yuan per square meter, yet the reporter found that manufacturers were quoting prices of around 200 yuan per square meter.
Cost has become the Achilles’ heel for all fire door manufacturers!
Steel fire doors are also seeing declining quality due to cost pressures. A reporter from Southern Weekend found that, for fire doors conforming to standard opening dimensions, the lowest quoted price (excluding tax) is 640 yuan per unit, while the highest reaches 740 yuan per unit; most quotes cluster around 680 yuan.
Li, the sales manager at Zhejiang Furui Industrial and Trading Company in Yongkang’s Xiangzhu Industrial Zone, told a reporter from Southern Weekend that doors priced at just over 600 yuan are not genuine fire doors; to the untrained eye, they are indistinguishable—whether in terms of their structural design or their fire‑resistant seals and locks.
Manager Li of the Sales Department at Yongkang Feitian Door Industry Co., Ltd. admitted that, according to international standards, a Class B steel fire door would cost at least 1,000 yuan to produce.
Several corporate sales representatives admitted that their companies’ steel fire doors can pass routine on-site inspections and fire‑safety acceptance tests, but they fail under actual fire‑testing conditions—exposing their true shortcomings when subjected to standard‑compliant fire‑resistance assessments. Sales staff from these manufacturers cautioned a Southern Weekend reporter to cultivate strong relationships with local fire‑department authorities and do everything possible to avoid being referred for fire‑testing.
“Special-Access Door,” Ironclad Connections
Of course, if a company doesn’t want to be exposed during inspections, there’s another option: purchasing doors specifically designed for security checks.
“If you’re sending your products for fire‑inspection, please let us know in advance—we can arrange a custom‑made inspection gate just for you,” sales managers from Yongkang fire‑door manufacturers told reporters, offering practical advice on how to handle the situation should an unexpected spot check occur.
Lü Jiali, deputy general manager of Zhejiang Yongkang Intelligent Industry and Trade Co., Ltd., explained that the doors submitted to the relevant authorities for inspection each cost just over 1,000 yuan apiece. The ingredients, density, and adhesive quality of the fireproof door core panels all differ from those used in standard production.
The sales manager of Zhejiang Jinggang Power Machinery Co., Ltd. revealed, “The inspection gate is costly and must be performed manually, making it impossible to integrate into the production line.”
During his visit to Jinhemei Company, the reporter observed a bustling production workshop for wooden fire doors. Hu Qiang told the reporter that Jinhemei is also expanding into another line of business: manufacturing specialized fire doors used by other companies for certification and inspection purposes.
According to Hu Qiang, obtaining certification to manufacture fire doors requires passing a fire‑resistance test conducted by the national testing center. Some companies seeking such certification lack the capability to produce compliant fire doors themselves and therefore outsource production to firms like Jinhemei. Naturally, the price of these doors is exorbitant: “Each door costs 80,000 yuan, and we guarantee it will pass the test.”
Many companies told reporters that the results of current fire door inspections are easily influenced by the subjective judgments of inspectors: “If they let you pass, you pass; if they don’t, you don’t.”
According to sources from relevant enterprises in Wuyi County, they routinely offer inspectors red envelopes when submitting fire doors for testing. “In Shandong, getting a Class B door certified requires a bribe of 10,000 yuan.”
However, those with strong ties to the local fire department need not worry about inspections.
A sales manager at a company in Wuyi County assured reporters that there would be no issues with the fire‑safety inspection, adding that their good relations with the regulatory authorities meant “even if they did set it on fire, it would still pass.” The manager also noted that his company’s fire doors perform flawlessly across the Jiangsu–Zhejiang–Shanghai region and in Beijing, thanks to their strong ties with local fire‑safety authorities.
(Source: Southern Weekend; Authors: Liu Chang, Zhang Weilong)